Thursday, October 14, 2010

Pat's Drafting Success 2000-2008

A poster yesterday at Football Outsiders got the hamster rolling in my head, in making a comment about the Patriots "never missing on a top ten draft pick". Notwithstanding that the Pats have only picked in the top ten twice under Bill Belichick (Seymour in 2001 and Mayo in 2008), the comment got me thinking.

I believe it was in an earlier comment that I laid out my general thoughts on draft success. As a quick recap, here is what I remember them as;

1) If a team never misses on their first round picks, they will be a perennial playoff team. The team that springs to mind is the Baltimore Ravens of the last fifteen years. And yes, I know they won a Super Bowl, but we are making generalizations here.
2) If a team wants to get to the next level, they need to acquire a starter from each draft in the later rounds. In this case, I think of the Colts, who pair an other-worldly offense with a defense that seems to pluck guys from the depths of the draft every season.
3) To get to the cream of the crop, say a five-year run of dominance, a team needs to find at least one starter in the later rounds, and more importantly, a few Pro Bowlers have to be dug out of the later rounds. The Patriots of 2001-2007 spring most to mind in this category.

To that end, I checked Pro Football Reference's draft database, and looked at the Pats drafting success under Bill Belichick. Here is a breakdown of AVERAGE Annual Value (a PPR rating system used to compare players across history), by draft year;

2000 24.4
2001 25.1
2002 18.3
2003 36.3
2004 17.0
2005 34.1
2006 19.0
2007 6.7
2008 12.5

The 2000 draft is discolored by the fact that Tom Brady alone produced 104 career AV out of a total draft class of 159. Patrick Pass, picked in the 7th round, contributed 15 AV over a seven year Patriots career. 2001 brought Richard Seymour and Matt Light, starters from day one that contributed greatly to the Pats 2001 Super Bowl victory. These two combine for 151 out of 164 total AV for the 2001 draft. 2002 brought Daniel Graham (1st), Deion Branch (2nd), Jarvis Green (4th) and David Givens (7th), who contributed 32, 38, 22 & 28 AV respectively, as well as winning a Super Bowl MVP in Branch. The 2003 draft is, in my opinion, the cream of the crop, returning Ty Warren (1st), Eugene Wilson (2nd), Asante Samuel (4th), Dan Koppen (5th) and Tully Banta-Cain (7th), with career AVs of 44, 29, 55, 48 and 19 respectively. All of these players, with the possible exception of TBC, were key contributors in the 2003 Super Bowl. And TBC has been the Pats best pass-rusher in his second go-round with the team.
The 2004 draft was the worst draft of the Pats dynasty, returning only Vince Wilfork and Ben Watson, both 1st round picks. Not that they were not great (in Wilfork's case) or good (in Watson's case), but there were no late round wins. Wilfork and Watson contributed 46 and 29 AV respectively in their Pats careers.
The 2005 draft could also vie with 2003 for the best draft class of the decade, returning Logan Mankins (1st), Ellis Hobbs (3rd), Nick Kaczur (3rd), James Sanders (4th) and Matt Cassel (7th). These players brought 46, 25, 35, 19 and 25 AV respectively, including Cassel's saving of the Pat's season when Tom Brady was injured in week 1 of the 2008 season.
The drafting began to go downhill in 2006, with only Laurence Maroney (1st) and Stephen Gostkowski (4th) starting for the Pats. 2007 brought only Brandon Meriweather in the 1st, and 8 misses in rounds 4-7. 2008 is too early to judge, although Jerod Mayo looks very good, he stands as the only starter from that class as well.

You can trace, by draft success, the Pats "struggles" of the last three seasons. Having an elite quarterback, of Tom Brady's caliber, probably guarantees you an 8 win season, but the defensive core got old from 2005-2008, and only a second cornerback and third safety were added to the mix.

The early returns on the 2009 draft are promising, as Patrick Chung has played pretty well so far in 2010, Sebastian Vollmer has played solid for a season and a quarter, Brandon Tate has a chance at the #3 WR role and Julian Edelman looks like he could eventually grow into another Pats slot-success story. The jury is still out on other picks from 2009, like Darius Butler, Ron Brace and Tyrone McKenzie. If the Pats are to prolong their window beyond 2011, these young players will have to continue to develop.

Back in the Saddle

Just logged onto the site, and saw that the last post was from the summer of 2009. Just to let our faithful reader know, we are back in the saddle for the 2010/11 fantasy football season. Weekly player rankings and random musings to follow...

Thursday, July 30, 2009

Jim Johnson

Eagles Defensive Coordinator Jim Johnson passed away yesterday at the too young age of 68. My experience with the Eagles has been limited to the few times they played the Pats in the pre-season, and any of the post-season games they were involved in. I am not at that level of game-watching to know what schemes he was throwing out, but by God, the man's defenses always played well.

The Eagles fetish for using crappy wide-receivers has really hurt their offense this decade, and a thought passes through my mind that they may have wasted the efforts of Johnson, whose defense carried the Eagles for much of his tenure.

I never met the man, never shook his hand, and obviously was never a player for him, but by all accounts he was a good and honest man, and the passing of any of those is to be lamented.

In Madden, for Playstation, a game that by rights should have worn out long-ago from overuse, Johnson is invariably the first man to make a head coach in the offseason. Recent rumors, which were proved to be all too true yesterday, probably kept him from ever reaching that plateau. Maybe, given the relative lack of success of other brilliant one-dimensional coordinators, it is better for his legacy that he did not. In any case, the Eagles has lost a faithful servant and the NFL has lost one of its most innovative minds. Rest in Peace.

"You're All That We Have, That's Why We Won't Use You"

The Hazean has released a list of his most over-valued receivers in 2009. Number one on the list is Dwayne Bowe, a member in good standing of Matt Calvey Inc., and a resident binky of this blog.

Hazean's commentary, in its entirety;
"He put up great numbers considering the anemic nature of the Chiefs offense last year, and did it with a smodge-podge of quarterbacks. When Tyler Thigpen is chucking the rock 30 times per game and you still are pulling down fat fantasy stat lines, your hype is sure to go through the roof.
And that is what Bowe’s stock has done. Now with a more competent — at least from the early returns — quarterback behind center, Bowe is expected to elevate last year’s numbers. But that will be hard to do with no Tony Gonzalez to keep pass defenses honest and hardly a semblance of a running game. Bowe should have a good year for sure, but top-12 territory is a stretch."

Let's undress this, piece by piece, as all undressing should be done...

1) "He put up great numbers, considering the anemic nature of the Chiefs offense..."
Regardless of the wisdom of trading for Matt Cassel, or whether or not he deserved the extension he received from the Chiefs, I think we can all agree, Matt Cassel > Tyler Thigpen. Let's call this a net plus for Bowe's catch percentage of one percent.

2) "But that will be hard to do with no Tony Gonzalez..."
According to The Fantasy Men's Law of Only Being Able to Throw to One Receiver Per Play, on each pass play, only one receiver can be thrown the ball, if a forward throw occurs. Tony Gonzalez was thrown the ball 121 times last year, a prodigious amount of targets for a TE (and he deserved every one of them, by the way). With no Tony Gonzalez this year, what happens to those 121 pass attempts? If you guessed, "A ton of them will be going to Dwayne Bowe", you are ready to move to 201. Matt Cassel is not going to call a play with the tight end as the primary option, realize it is not Tony Gonzalez, and throw the ball to the center. He will look for OTHER options to fill the void left by Gonzalez, and Bowe stands ready to benefit from this increased targeting. Let's assume he receives one third of these targets, rounding down to forty.

Now, I MIGHT grant that defenses will focus extra attention on Dwayne Bowe this season (whatever the hell that cliched concept means; do you really think the defense assigned eleven guys to follow Gonzo and screamed at Thigpen that Bowe wasn't open?), and I will say, for the sake of counter-weighting my argument, that this extra "attention", drops Bowe's catch rate four percent.

Now, what does all our black-magic do to Bowe's production? Last season, he was targeted 142 times, catching the ball 59% of the time, for a total of 86 catches, 1,022 yards and 7 TDs.

If we assume everything above, he will now be targeted 182 times, catching the ball 56% of the time, which translates to; 102 catches, for 1,213 yards and 8 TDs. Is that an unreasonable stat line for a guy that has more catches in his first two seasons than Reggie Wayne had in his first THREE years (with a much, much better QB and a much better "ground game", which is apparently important for receivers). Simply put, Dwayne Bowe's career production in his first two years puts him into elite company, and it is not a stretch to say in ten years, he could be a legitimate candidate for the Hall of Fame, based on his early career trends.

Pass-catching, for a receiver, is the intersection of two events, a target, and a catch. If your team is trailing, you will be targeted more. If your QB is better, you will catch more of those targets. If your running game is cruddy, you will also be targeted more. If your defense is crap, you will be trailing more late in the game, and you will be targeted more. All of these apply for Bowe this season, as he enters his magical third season in the league. That stat line above would not surprise me in the least. I would grab Bowe in the second round in any format.

Monday, June 29, 2009

The Experts Strike Again

Over on KFFL, fantasy football expert Bryce McRae informs us that Oakland Raiders TE Zach Miller is a second year tight end. If a history "expert" told you that Abraham Lincoln was the worst Chief Justice in Supreme Court history, they probably wouldn't be called an expert too much longer.

Thursday, May 28, 2009

I'm Not Sold on Lee Evans

Fantasy Football Librarian (much, much higher on the "must-read" pecking order than this rag) links today to an article about the apparent rise in value of Lee Evans, now that Terrell Owens is in town. The theory goes that a second wide-receiver that is a threat to catch the ball will "distract" attention, or will command part of the coverage, that has inhibited Lee Evans from realizing his potential. I am unsure of the central premise of this line of thought.
Last season, the Buffalo Bills attempted, collectively, 479 passes. This does not count sacks and non-designed QB runs. Lee Evans caught 63 of those passes. I don't have the catch percentage statistics from last season yet, but let's ASSUME that he caught 55% of his passes (he has never posted a very high percentage, if my memory serves, but I will validate this after I return from vacation). That would mean that he was thrown the ball about 114 times, let's call it 115 targets. That means that 364 passes were thrown to other receivers than Lee Evans last year. Now, two things will happen with this bundle of numbers that will have a countervailing impact on Lee Evans' production this season;
1) Terrell Owens will receive more targets than Josh Reed did last year
2) Opposing teams will play their #1 CB on Owens instead of Evans
The first will result in fewer targets for Evans, the second will result in a higher catch rate (presumably) for Evans. I see no reason why either should cancel the other out. If he gets 20 fewer targets, which is a moderately small estimate, he would need to improve his catch percentage by 11 points to have the same production! A dicey proposition at best. The only gain to Evan's production that I can foresee therefore, comes from one of two possibilities;
1) His catch rate improves DRAMATICALLY. By this I mean at least 15%.
2) The Buffalo offense throws the ball at LEAST 550 times. Assuming he gets 25% of targets, this would translate to 8-10 additional catches. The issue also arises that Evans only received 25% of his targets as the teams #1, what percent is reasonable to expect as the #2? For the record, he was dinged up last year, and that certainly comes into consideration, but was he lighting it up at the beginning of the season?
In summary, I don't know if I buy the angle that a #1 receiver gets a boost from another #1 receiver coming to the team. Definitionally, only one pass attempt can be made per play, and T.O is certainly going to get his share of those attempts (a much higher percentage, we can surmise, than Josh Reed got as the other receiver last year). If Terrell Owens gets as many looks as Lee Evans received last year, it is hard for me to predict an increase in production from Lee Evans, unless Buffalo is prepared to throw the ball 600 times next season.

Monday, April 27, 2009

Detroit Lions Select...

I had intended to post the Detroit Lions "alternate" first overall pick prior to the draft, but have been busy at my real job, and have not had the time to post. Suffice to say, The Fantasy Men do NOT like the Matthew Stafford selection, for which a bit of a background may be in order.
There was a great article posted on Football Outsiders, I believe it was last week, talking about the "draft" (quotation marks for a reason) and its correlation to team success. A central, albeit underdeveloped tenet, of the article was that the actual draft itself is a very small part of what is generally considered to be a successful, or failed, draft.
As important, and perhaps MORE important, is the development that comes AFTER the draft. Take two players of equal talent, put them in vastly different scenarios, and the output will be vastly different. Only the very special player can rise above organizational malaise, and I haven't seen anything to lead me to believe that Matthew Stafford is that player. Simply put, I don't know (nor obviously does anyone) whether Matthew Stafford will be a great NFL player, an average player, or a complete washout. However, I DO know that the Lions do not yet have a system and the tools in place to allow him to grow to his full potential.
To that end, were the Lions to come to the light, and hire The Fantasy Men as co-GMs (or me as GM, and Steve as my coffee guy), our draft board top 5 would look like this;

1) Eugene Monroe
2) Jason Smith
3) B.J Raji
4) Aaron Curry
5) Michael Oher

I am NOT saying that these are the best 5 players in the draft, but these players, I think, provide the largest marginal return to a rebuilding Lions program. Look, no matter what the Lions do, they are not going to contend for a Super Bowl at any point in the next two years, which is both a bad thing and an opportunity, since it allows the Lions to totally clean house, and restock their cupboard for the future. I worry that picking Matthew Stafford #1 here will lead to a spiraling problem in future years, where the organization feels the need to get him "weapons", a la the Indianapolis Colts, and ignore more pressing needs. The presence of three offensive tackles in our top 5 also allows us to use some small bit of leverage in the pre-draft negotiations. The contract handed over to Matthew Stafford will probably never be justified from the Lions end, since they are paying something like $9-13mm real value every year, for a QB that alone will not be able to fix their woes.
The Lions had a real chance to begin the long turnaround process this weekend, and I am afraid they chose poorly...

Friday, February 6, 2009

Matt Cassel to Detroit

With the recent application of the Franchise Tag to Matt Cassel, the rumor mill is in full swing regarding his (seemingly) inevitable trade FROM the Patriots once a certain Brady fellow returns from injury.

The Fantasy Men, literally swamped with fan mail regarding the possibility of Cassel suiting up for the Lions next year, have finally deigned to put their feelings on paper (as it were).

The Lions currently have two first round picks, "winning'' the 1st overall pick for their (lack of) effort this past season, and the 20th overall from the Cowboys for their trade of Roy Williams. Is there a word for the opposite of theft, where you give someone something that ruins them? Whatever it was, the Lions did THAT to the Cowboys in getting a first (plus).

These are some of the packages I would offer for Cassel, since (in this world), I run the Lions;

1) The 20th overall pick, with a conditional 2010 pick (capped at a 2nd rounder for a division title or something). This gives the Pats a first rounder, and allows us to use the 1st overall pick on a stud offensive or defensive lineman, which are both safer picks than QB AND would solve more of an IMMEDIATE need. It also protects us from overpaying for a guy that has limited game experience.
2) Leigh Bodden, the 20th pick and a 4th rounder. Everything we hear out of Detroit (wait a minute...) indicates that the Lions are thinking about cutting Bodden. Let's see if a change of scenery will do a body good.
3) Our second round pick this year, and a first next year. This might pose the most tempting target, IF the Pats think the Lions will continue to waddle in the cesspool, and allows the Lions to use two first round picks this year to shore up their team. Of course, both picks need to be hits to ensure future success.

Of the three, I think the first appeals most to me. And yes, I do think Matt Cassel is worth a 1st round pick. Matthew Stafford may be the best QB ever to play in the NFL, or he may be the worst. At least with Cassel, you know he can be an above average QB in the NFL.

Tuesday, December 30, 2008

Out-thinking Youselves

With more than a neutral interest in the Jets-Dolphins tilt this past Sunday, I found myself for the second time this decade cheering for a Brett Favre led team playing in New York in week 17, in order to get the Pats the division title. For the second time, Brett Favre, as is his wont, played like some bearded Kyle Boller, and made the Pats the best of the rest, instead of one of the hopefuls.
One thing that the Fantasy Men could not fathom, was the complete disappearance of the Jets running game. On the day, the Jets handed off to their running backs 20 times, which does not seem low, until you realize that Brett Favre was called upon in a big game, to throw the ball 40 times. I am not one of those people that thinks that magically, if you get to 30 runs, you will be gifted 50 points and win the game, but there is something to be said for maintaining a committment to the running game, a committment that was lacking from the Jets. Since the middle of the season, when the media ripped Eric Mangina for not passing in the red zone, it seems that he has progressively eschewed (what verbose word usage!) the running game, in favor of placing his fortunes on Brett Favre's ailing and decrepit shoulder. In a related note, Eric Mangina is presently seeking employment.
In the first quarter, the Jets ran 3 times, not including one play called back for holding. In the second quarter, they ran only 4 times. In the third, the ball was run 7 times, and in the fourth, 6 more.
The Jets had to have known what we have discovered in hindsight, that Brett Favre was hurt, and Mangina should have been able to see with his own eyes that Favre was not as effective as he should have been, to be throwing the ball 40 times a game.
Sometimes, doing the simple things can win you games. Running on first down gets you into more manageable second downs. Running on third down when you know you are going for it on fourth down shortens the distance for you. The running game is what you do to salt away a win, but there is a place for it throughout the game as well.
The Jets offensive line has been one of the teams strengths this year, and their failure to turn to their ground game in their must win week 17 game was a large factor in their loss.

Wednesday, December 24, 2008

Boldin or Colston; Revisited

On November 13th, I posited that I would rather have Marques Colston than Anquan Boldin for the duration of the fantasy season. With the ending of 95% of fantasy leagues this past weekend, it is time to revisit my "prediction".

Since that prediction, the players starts are as follows;

Boldin
40 Catches
432 Yards
1 Touchdown
10 Rushing Yards
3 Fumbles / 2 Fumbles Lost

This equates to about 46 fantasy points, assuming no fractionals, and no points for fumbles not lost.

Colston
28 Catches
415 Yards
4 Touchdowns

This equates to 47 points, assuming scoring above. Note that Marques Colston does not have a single rushing or passing attempt in his entire career, which is strange for a guy that has been basically his teams #1 WR from Day One.

I guess I can claim victory here, especially given the extreme negative reaction I received around the office when touting my theory.

Friday, December 19, 2008

Kevin Seifert Joins the Team

Since my adoption of the Lions, pro-bono of course, numerous commentators have decided to glom on to my fame and renown, and have taken it upon themselves to assist me in my unenviable task of rebuilding the Detroit Kitty-Cats. The latest example is Kevin Seifert of ESPN.com. For once, most of this column actually makes sense, but since a large part of his advice is on the operational end of things, only a smattering of things applies to our brief. Kevin's points, and my rejoinders, follow;

"3. Put Rod Marinelli out of his misery. Marinelli might be a good football coach, but no one can lose so many games in a such a short period while maintaining credibility inside or outside the organization. I know, Marinelli hasn't been blessed with the NFL's best personnel. But it's hard to convince anyone you're moving forward with a coach who has lost 36 of 46 games over a three-year tenure."

I have said, offline, innumerable times, that we live in a society that worships leadership and accountability. This is a good thing. Part of the reason, regardless of your politics, that George Bush's approval ratings nose-dived at the end of 2005 is that he was perceived as failing to lead the rescue/evacuation/clean-up surrounding Rita and Katrina. Fair or not, his administration and party have paid a great price for this failure. It is oft the same in professional football. We assume Bill Belichick is a legendary coach because of his wins and losses, but we have NO WAY of knowing how he would do with this Lions team.
For my part, I am inclined to keep Marinelli for another season. Coaching stability is a plus, allowing teams to develop a sense of consistency from player evaluation, all the way through to practice methods. The Washington Redskins have spent enormous sums of money and draft picks this century, constantly churning and turning over their rosters and coaching staff. And what have they shown for their millions? One playoff win?
No, Rod Marinelli MAY be part of the problem, but we are determined to give him another year to show that he can address his shortcomings.
Listen, NO coach will make the playoffs with this roster next year (unless they get to move to the NFC west), so bringing in another guy to install another system doesn't help the young players that are on this team, and that will be added during this off season. This is a legitimate three year rebuilding process. If Marinelli can't hack it with an improving roster, then we cut our losses, and give the new guy a window to work in, but I can't approve of firing coaches who struggle to win with rosters composed of guys that might not start in Division II college ball.

"7. Rebuild both lines. The Lions, especially on defense, get pushed around on the line of scrimmage far too often for an NFL team. It's the most basic requirement in football: You must be able to move people out of your way. The Lions can't, at least not often enough. (Evidence: They rank No. 32 in the NFL in rush defense and No. 31 in rush offense). This is a difficult task and could take several drafts to complete. But if they focus on nothing else, the Lions must address this physical mismatch."

Amen, 100% agreement. Almost every mock draft I have seen has the Lions drafting Matt Stafford 1st overall. This would not happen were I running this team. We may trade out of the 1st, we may keep it, we may light ourselves on fire on the stage, but we will NOT be drafting an offensive "skill position" player in the first round.

"8. Because they need such a talent influx on the line and elsewhere, the Lions should trade down in the 2009 draft and perhaps in 2010 as well. For now, focus on numbers rather than blue-chip possibilities. Trades don't happen too often at the highest levels of the draft, but the expected class of 2009 quarterbacks should entice someone to make a deal."

There is wisdom in trading down, but for every seller you need a buyer. The Lions SHOULD try and trade down, but if no one wants the first pick, we have to use it, but the thinking behind this pick is sound.

"9. Establish a practice of drafting safely at the top end of the draft and take your risks in lower rounds. The Lions are a case study in the impact of missing consistently with high, and at times, risky draft choices. (See Rogers, Charles; Harrington, Joey; and Williams, Mike). If you have the proverbial choice between Jake Long and Darren McFadden, take Long. No need to swing for the fence when average is a big improvement."

This is a no duh! type statement, but is is also an example of hind-sight being 20-20. Take a look at this search on ESPN.com ( http://search.espn.go.com/charles-rogers/mel-kiper-jr./4294801923 ) The search is full of praise from Mel Kiper for the Lions adding an "impact player" in Charles Rogers, and saying that whatever team added Mike Williams was going to get a "great player". The Lions got both, and they both suck. Wide receiver is a dangerous position to pick at the top of the draft (Football Outsiders has done yeoman's work on this subject), but to pretend that there was some universal consensus that these guys would be bums is completely farcical. They were RISKIER picks than other guys available, but no one could know how BAD they would turn out to be. Imagine an alternate universe, where Joey Harrington is throwing to the first quadruplet receivers to ever go over 1,000 yards in a season, and their offense is putting up 45 points a game. Not too unrealistic, IF those picks worked out. I didn't think they were good picks at the time, but the criticism was positional, not player skill based.

"10. Resist the temptation to draft a blue-chip quarterback immediately. The Lions are a year or more away from being the 2008 Falcons, who selected Matt Ryan No. 3 overall and inserted him immediately into what surprisingly turned out to be a playoff-caliber lineup. They should use their picks to create a good environment for any young quarterback they eventually draft. These days, teams can't draft a blue-chip quarterback and sit him on the bench for three years. And remember, for every Ryan there is a Harrington."

Poor Joseph Harrington gets no love. A one-time bust has turned into an above-replacement level quarterback. Maybe he looked bad because he was throwing to fat receivers, with no running backs and a Swiss cheese offensive line? Agree with the logic, but the blame may be misdirected.

"14. Make it a priority to find a capable No. 2 receiver opposite of Calvin Johnson. We've seen how Johnson can beat a double team by simply reaching over smaller defenders. But the Lions could benefit more from that double coverage. A competent No. 2 receiver, or even a top pass-catching tight end, could clean up while playing next to Johnson. A good coach could build his offense around the idea that he'll always have a mismatch somewhere in the passing game."

A decent #2 WR is always a bonus in your offense, but young WR's take time to develop. In the off season, I will be exploring the possibility of either a trade, or RFA plays. I think, if Cleveland is selling, Braylon Edwards could be a great option on the backside of the field from Calvin Johnson, scaring the hell out of safeties, and clearing out the short field for CJ and the tight ends.

Friday, December 12, 2008

Really ESPN

Checking my player comments, in setting my lineup for my first playoff game this weekend, (bye week last week), I ran across this gem;


"Edwards (groin) missed practice for the second straight day Thursday and is unlikely to play Sunday against the Jets, according to the Bills' official site. "It's better, but he did not participate at all," said coach Dick Jauron.
Spin: If Edwards had more experience, Jauron might let him play if he was able to practice Friday, but the coach thinks rookies need Thursday and Friday practice, so it seems he's on the edge of naming J.P. Losman the starter for Week 15. If you're in a league with a Thursday lineup deadline, absolutely do not start Edwards."

I, and every other fantasy owner who pays attention to their team, though that Edwards was drafted LAST YEAR by the Buffalo Bills, in the third round, out of Stanford. Glad ESPN is paying attention to their own comments...

Wednesday, November 26, 2008

What Would We Take for Tom Brady

A post on ColdHardFootballFacts.com asked a question, that four months ago, would have bordered on heresy here in the Northeast; "Should the Pats consider trading Tom Brady?"

The immediate, gut reaction of every New England fan would be "No". Imagine though, if some team (New Orleans in this example), called up and said; "We will give you Drew Brees, Marques Colston, Pierre Thomas and our first round pick in the next six drafts." THAT would be jumped on by the same percentage of New England fans.

Clearly, to paraphrase Winston Churchill, we know what we are willing to do, now we are just haggling over the price.

To that end, I have prepared a list of POTENTIAL trade partners, and what I would be willing to accept for Tom Brady. The following caveats apply;

1) We are ignoring cap accelerations.
2) We will NOT trade Tom Brady to any team in the AFC East.
3) Our asking price for the rest of the AFC would be higher than if we shipped him to an NFC team.

To that end, the list of teams that would have realistic interest in Tom Brady;

San Francisco
Detroit
Kansas City
Minnesota
Carolina
Tennessee
Philadelphia
Tampa Bay
Chicago

Philadelphia is on the list since it seems apparent that Donovan McNabb and the city need a separation. Tampa Bay has Jeff Garcia, but he is old.

I omitted Oakland, which SHOULD be on the list, due to the fact that they still have JaMarcus Russell, couldn't trade him, and couldn't possibly pay two quarterbacks a combined $30mm or so next year.

Here, then, are my terms;

San Francisco: Patrick Willis and three first round picks. Willis and Mayo could man the middle of the Patriots 3-4 defense for the next 10 years, and might be the first linebacker combo in history to combine for 400 tackles in a season. The first round draft picks reflect the fact that there aren't too may other good players in San Fran that I would be interested in. I know Clements is pretty good, and Gore is a very good running back, but there is only one RB in the league I would want to get in a trade (more on that later). Other than that, I don't think their roster has the depth we would need to receive in a trade.

Detroit: Calvin Johnson, Leigh Bodden and two first round picks. Megatron would add a third legitimately great receiver to the offense, and would ensure that on any given play, two of New Englands receiving options should be open. Leigh Bodden was a good cornerback in Cleveland, we are betting that a change of scenery would do him wonders. The first round picks are a little lower than for San Fran, because they may well both be #1 overall picks.

Kansas City: Dwayne Bowe and 4 first round picks. I don't trust the Tyler Thigpen experiment, and Bowe is the only player from Kansas City that I think provides a meaningful upgrade over New England. I understand Tony Gonzalez is better than Ben Watson, but he is also much older.

Minnesota: Adrian Peterson, Steve Hutchinson and a first round pick. Adrian Peterson is breath-taking to behold, and the thought of him running for MY team (other than my fantasy team) is heart warming. Steve Hutchinson is one of the best guards in this league, and would provide a pass-blocking (and health) upgrade over Stephen Neal, who could be moved to right tackle, or put into a rotation. The first round pick would be about mid-round as it appears now, and could be used for the best available player in the secondary.

Carolina: Jon Beason, Steve Smith and Johnathan Stewart. Another linebacker to plug in the middle, and two offensive upgrades. I didn't include Julius Peppers, because I don't think he would be as effective as an end in a 3-4 defense. If New England played the 4-3, the trade would be Peppers, Stewart and a first or something.

Tennessee: Cortland Finnegan, Chris Johnson and Michael Roos. This trade, above all others, I think provides the best return to the New England Patriots. Finnegan provides an immediate upgrade to the secondary, the biggest area of weakness on this team, allowing Ellis Hobbs to cover opposing #2s and Deltha O'Neal to go to hell. Chris Johnson is the two way threat New England thought they were getting when they drafted Laurence Maroney, and would also help my fantasy team, since the looming (and I mean looming, he is huge) specter of LenWhale White vulturing CJ's touchdowns would be erased. Roos has started every game since being drafted, and should make the Pro Bowl this year, providing an upgrade over Nick Kaczur. Three areas of need are ALL strengthened in this trade.

Philadelphia: Shawn Andrews and a ton of draft picks. I am really not too high on anyone in Phildelphia (I guess bringing Asante back would be great, but I still don't know). I guess the ton of draft picks allows the team to stockpile younger talent, but I couldn't see this working.

Tampa Bay: This is another team that doesn't have options at positions that I think New England needs. I guess something like every pick for the next four or five years.

Chicago: Ugh, another team that I don't really see matching up well with New England. Lance Briggs of course springs immediately to mind, as does Urlacher, but no way do they give up both. I guess Briggs and draft picks, and a ton of them.

I would be very excited to get a package like the one I detailed from Tennessee, especially if I could get draft picks involved in the mix too. New England has glaring needs in the defensive secondary, and has depth concerns in the trenches. That trade allows them to cover most of their needs, and to get young players involved in their plans for the future. Their window will run as long as their successful drafts, and plugging in players of Finnegan, Roos and Johnson's abilities may stretch that window a bit further.

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

Shame on You, Michael Fabiano

Look, I have NEVER pretended to watch every game. I don't tell you how a team handled a particular receiver, or how fast a certain running back looked in his three carries. I base my analysis off of numbers and trends, i.e; I don't start ANY #1 WR against Oakland, because I know what the production of receivers lined up against Nnamdi Asomugha is like.

Apparently, Michael Fabiano watches game film for every game, every week. Puh-lease! Writing in his column this week, Fabiano uncorks this blow-hard gem;

"Should I bench Chris Johnson this week? He's done nothing over the past two games and faces the Jets' tough run defense in Week 12. I can replace him with Tim Hightower or Marshawn Lynch. -- F. Classen, Denmark
M.F.: Johnson has seen his numbers fall over the last two weeks, as defenses have focused on stopping the run and challenged Kerry Collins to beat them."

Really? Johnson's numbers have declined because defenses have focused on stopping the run?

Are you sure it doesn't have to do with the fact that in one game, he played against the Chicago Bears, and their hold-every-RB-but-Adrian-Peterson-to-2-YPC-defense? And in the other game, Tennessee only got to run 57 offensive plays, with 16 of them running plays by LenWhale White and Kerry Collins? That leaves 41 plays, of which Johnson carried 17 times and caught four passes, for a total of 88 yards, hardly shut down.

Kerry Collins threw a pick on the opening drive, which cost Johnson potentially 3-6 carries. On the second drive, LenWhale got a 2 yard carry on 1st and 10 from the Jaguars 20, followed by an incomplete pass, and a short screen pass, field goal. A completion (or sequential runs on second down) and maybe Johnson gets 1-2 more plays on this drive. On the third drive, two LenWhale runs resulted in 6 yards, followed by another Kerry Collins incompletion on third down, another chance for Johnson to get carries forgone by a failure to convert third downs. On Tennessee's 4th drive, Johnson had a pair of four yard carries followed by ANOTHER incompletion on 3rd and 2 (why are you passing there?). Boom goes the punt, and out the window go another potential group of plays. On the next drive, a 3 yard run by Johnson, an incomplete pass and a false start lead to a 3rd and 12, with, you guessed it, ANOTHER Kerry Collins incompletion. Boom goes the punt, yadi yadi yada. The next drive, Johnson had 3 straight runs, and could not convert the third down. To this point, I think Tennessee is like 1-8 on 3rd downs. The punt is away, and Tennessee does not get the ball again in the half.

On the Titans first drive of the second half, a long return is followed by a couple of short passes, an 11 yard Chris Johnson run, and another 8 yard pass, with another Chris Johnson conversion. Johnson gets 2 yards to the 13, and the next play is a touchdown pass. On the NEXT drive, CJ has a 7 yard run on 1st down (come on Fabiano, I thought they were loading the box), followed by the 56 yard scoring pass to Justin Gage.

The fourth quarter emerges much the same. A team struggles on third down, but converts a bunch on long plays on first and second downs. The Titans were ONE FOR TWELVE on 3rd down conversions for the game, and THAT is why CJ struggled in this game (granted one was his fault). Kerry Collins completed three passes on third down all game, and two of them went for negative yardage. When you can't convert 3rd downs, your running backs see the field alot less than they should, and THAT is why CJ struggled. Give him 8 more carries at his average production, and you have 95 rushing yards to go with 24 receiving (assuming he didn't catch anything else). All of a sudden, we are talking about 120 all purpose yards.

Michael Fabiano can BS all he wants about schemes and whatnot, but the fact of the matter is that the Titans were dreadful on 3rd down, and that hurt CJ's touches a bunch in this game. Kerry Collins completed his passes on 1st and 2nd down, and they were long, flukish plays for the big scores.

He is a tough play this week against a pretty good Jets defense, but it has NOTHING to do with the Jets loading the box, and everything to do with what the NUMBERS tell you the Jets do to opposing running backs.

Lions on the Clock

As part of my research for our Dynasty Fantasy Football league, I have begun (began, begin, beganned?) to look into mock drafts for 2009. It is important to find rookie skill position players, or offensive lineman that will be drafted high to teams with YOUR skill position players. Many of the mocks I have seen have the Detroit Lions picking a QB 1st overall. I can assure you, under our management, that if the Lions lose out, and "win" the 1st pick in the 2009 draft, they will NOT be selecting a quarterback. A trade is possible, but right now we are biased towards Michael Oher. As noted before, I think winning teams build on the foundations of solid line play, and a rookie QB doesn't address that.

Thursday, November 13, 2008

Boldin or Colston

A co-worker was recently proposed a trade of either Anquan Boldin or Marques Colston for Jay Cutler (the co-worker would be the recipient of Cutler).

Near universal consensus would say that Boldin is the MUCH better option, but I told him that were I making the trade, I would give away Boldin over Colston (and this is not an insignificant point, I have both receivers on my one fantasy team.

Both Colston and Boldin are elite talents when healthy, and Colston missed a month and a half with a broken thumb, and was held without a reception in his first game back from injury. In his most recent game, he had 7 catches for 140 yards, so I think it is safe to say that he has recovered from the thumb.

My logic, or basis, for saying that I would keep Colston over Boldin is due to the inherent unpredictability of wide receiver touchdowns. Boldin has been the #1 WR in value under my fantasy league's scoring format (I think we can say he is no more than top 5 in ANY realistic scoring format). Colston, obviously would be lucky to get into the top 75, given that he has played like 3 real games.

What concerns me about Boldin is a regression to the mean happening during the season. Last week is a good example, when he had two TDs against the 49ers. His second TD "catch" was actually a screen pass, where Boldin caught the ball on the five yard line, knifed inside and under one defender, and came down 0.000000000000000001 inches inside of the end zone. In fact, his first TD was a great individual effort as well, as he juked one defender out, and ran past (or between) two more. These were great individual plays, but are also two very CLOSE plays. Imagine he comes down 0.0000000000000001 inches OUTSIDE of the end zone, or the defender juked on the first score bumps him and slows him down. Now Boldin has 5 catches for 50 yards (or something) and NO scores. Not that it did happen, but it JUST AS EASILY could have happened.

The example I bring up is of Reggie Williams from last season, when he had 38 catches and 10 TDs. In some formats, he would be a top 5 or top 10 receiver (depending on TD weight). This season he is on pace for 36 catches and 2 TDs. A lot of fantasy owners drafted him expecting 50-60 catches and 10 more TDs, and are being disappointed.

When I look at running backs, I look at TDs, since a running back that gets goal line carries can have his value highly inflated (LenWhale White, I am looking at you!). Receiver TDs however, I don't value as highly as catches and yards.

Give me a receiver with 100 catches and 2 scores over a guy with 50 catches and 9-10 scores, and I think more often than not, in the NEXT season, that 100 catch guy will VASTLY outperform the 50 catch gentleman.

In a roundabout way, I am less optimistic that Anquan Boldin will put up the points he has put up for the rest of the season, and I fear an in-season regression to the mean.

Wednesday, October 15, 2008

Shorthanded Results of Draft Success

I have been thinking, for some time, how teams success can be correlated to their success on Draft Day. I think a shorthanded way of looking at it can apply, in general cases;

1) If a team NEVER hits on draft picks (or very rarely), you get a crud team. The Detroit Lions and Oakland Raiders of the last couple of years are good examples of this, and not coincidentally, are among the two worst franchises since 2002. Namdi Asomugha is obviously a GREAT player, and my pick for best defensive back in the NFL today, but by and large, these teams have whiffed time and again.

2) If a team makes solid picks in the first round, it will be competitive. The best example I can think of for first round drafting is probably San Diego, although there are extenuating circumstances to all of their picks. They have not yet made a Super Bowl in their run, but have mixed mostly good years in with some mediocre years. If your team JUST hits their first round picks, this is probably the ceiling. Note that I say San Diego, which is German for a whale's vagina, is the CEILING, since they have had some success in the later rounds.

3) If your team hits on half of their late round picks, you will have a dominant franchise. The best two examples are the Pats of 2000-2004 and the Colts of the last eight years. Everyone knows about Tom Brady, but lesser known picks have been very important to the teams run of dominance as well. Dan Koppen was a 5th round pick that started most of his rookie season. David Givens was a 7th round pick from Notre Dame that was a great possession receiver before he left New England and came down with Belichick's Revenge. Asante Samuel was a 4th round pick, yadi yadi yada. The Colts have similar success stories scattered around their roster. Teams that hit in the late rounds, in addition to hitting early, will compete for Super Bowls for longer windows than teams that mix booms and busts. A large part of the Pats weaknesses this year (aside from Brady obviously) is the paucity of players from the last three drafts. Note that the jury is still out on the Giants. Last years draft looks good, but I don't think Kevin Boss is as good as fans think he is, and we don't know if they will continue to build on their late round mining, or if it was a flash in the pan.

Notice that first and foremost, successful franchises are predicated on solid play from the QB position. In addition to my belief that a team should grab AT LEAST one offensive and defensive lineman per year, I don't think teams would be too amiss were they to DRAFT one QB every other year, and sign one rookie to the practice squad every other year. The Colts, for all their successes, have been quite lucky with Peyton Manning's health, and have nothing behind Jim Sorgi. Grooming young QBs in the system is a smart option that all teams can take advantage of.

Tooting My Own Horn

Not to brag, but since the "adoption" of the Detroit Lions by this blog, we have proposed two moves, trading Jon Kitna to see if Orlovsky is worth anything, and trading Roy Williams. The Lions must be readers, having, in the last week, traded Roy Williams to Dallas, and, attempted to trade Jon Kitna before placing him on IR, to see what they have in Orlovsky.

Friday, October 3, 2008

How Bad Is the Detroit Lions Run Defense

In 1976, the New England Patriots rushed for a team NFL record 2,948 yards. Offensive lineman John Hannah (maybe the best offensive lineman in history, and still the best player in Patriots history) led the way for a team that averaged an almost unfathomable 210 yards per game (they played 14 games that season). The Detroit Lions are allowing 207.7 yards per game. That means, for the lay person, that if a team got to play the Detroit Lions 16 times (we should all be so lucky!), there is a legitimate shot at that team rushing for 3,323 yards. If you figure the #1 RB gets 60% of his teams rushing yardage (not sure on the actual rate, I think it's a good enough guess), your fantasy runner could put up about 1,994 yards over a sixteen game schedule. If you have a team with more of a feature back, like Buffalo, or San Francisco, they could easily challenge Dickerson's all time single season record.

That is why I said no matter what, start ANY running back you have against the Lions, particularly when he is as much the focus of his team's offense as Matt Forte is. If you plug in his expected output of 60% of 207.7, you get 125 yards or so. THEN you add in any TDs, receiving yards, and receiving TDs. I'm not going to project the fantasy game of the season (AP still gets to run against them), but is 25 points unreasonable? Absolutely not.

Thursday, October 2, 2008

Week 5 WR Rankings

Week 5 WRs;

1) Brandon Marshall
2) Terrell Owens
3) Larry Fitzgerald
4) Steve Smith
5) Reggie Wayne
6) Calvin Johnson
7) Andre Johnson
8) Greg Jennings
9) Santana Moss
10) T.J Houshmandzadeh
11) DeSean Jackson
12) Wes Welker
13) Randy Moss
14) Lee Evans
15) Roy Williams
16) Dwayne Bowe
17) Chris Chambers
18) Roddy White
19) Eddie Royal
20) Hines Ward
21) Lance Moore
22) Robert Meachem
23) Chad Johnson
24) Donald Driver
25) Antonio Bryant

Brandon Marshall's touchdown catch last week was incredible, and not to beat a dead horse, but this guy was available in the fourth round. You think Philadelphia or Seattle might like him right now? If I were a baseball coach, I would list Fitzgerald and Steve Smith as "Fitzy" and "Smitty", but I'm not, so they go by their Christian names with me. The brothers Johnson both represent their teams best options to attack opposing pass defenses, and I see them being pretty productive. DeSean Jackson is bucking the trend of rookie receivers, although I hope he doesn't deliberately fumble at the one yard line this week. Randy Moss is slipping lower and lower, as a Pats fan, this bugs me, as a non-Moss owner, I love it. Revenge game for Chris Chambers? Moore and Meachem will get plenty of looks from Brees, and certainly Meachem is capable of turning three looks into two catches for one hundred and seventy two yards. Donald Driver is not performing as I had hoped, he may be taking a vacation from these lists shortly.